Just how far is too far? - It's a good question. One that should seriously be considered, but do you want Hollywood deciding how far the "sophisticated" dialog goes in children's movies?
Here's a rather telling quote from Robin Williams on SCI FI Wire:
Robin Williams, who voices a character in the upcoming computer-animated Robots movie, told SCI FI Wire that he loves doing voice-over work for animated films. "It's the closest thing you can get to doing standup other than HBO, where you're free," Williams said in an interview. "Yes, there are certain boundaries, because it's a kids' movie or a PG, but now, given the level of sophistication of children, even that's been pushed."
I believe it gives you an idea about what some in Hollywood are thinking.
Consider too, the skit Williams did in a 2000 DNC tribute to President Clinton which contained profanity and sexual connotations even though a child was in the front row.
Something to consider the next time your standing in line at the cinema or video rental line.
Update: 2005.02.25.
This is interesting.
The day after posting this, I learn of Variety's release of this: F-bombs catch a break MPAA lets 'Palace' push profanity limits.
This item is about what is being labeled as a documentary titled "Gunner Palace." It a film about U.S. soldiers hunkered down in Uday's palace in Iraq. Of course "Fahrenheit 9/11" and "Bowling for Columbine" were also called documentaries. Which isn't to say that "Gunner Palace" isn't a true docu, it's just that trust is sorely bruised.
The folk working on this film didn't want the "R" rating that the MPAA originally gave it because of the strong use of obscenities, drug references and violent situations. However, Gabriel Snyder and Ian Mohr report for Variety that the people behind "Gunner Palace" appealed the rating ruling because they felt teenagers interested in going to the military should be aware of what goes on in a war zone. I would contend that a two hour movie, documentary or not, cannot clearly represent what happens in a war.
So, apparently some with tears in their eyes, the MPAA reversed their original rating and awarded "Gunner Palace" a "PG-13" rating.
Synder and Mohr write:
Last summer, the producers and distribs of "Fahrenheit 9/11" made a nearly identical but unsuccessful case to appeal their R rating.
Hat tip to the Drudge Report.
Recent Comments